City of Charlotte Banner
File #: 15-20323    Version: 1 Name:
Type: Policy Item Status: Agenda Ready
File created: 5/3/2023 In control: City Council Business Meeting
On agenda: 5/22/2023 Final action:
Title: Updated Process for Appointed Staff Performance Evaluations
Attachments: 1. BGIR HR pre-read for 5.1.2023, 2. Proposed Evaluation Proc for Appointed
Title
Updated Process for Appointed Staff Performance Evaluations

Action
Action:
Approve the Budget, Governance, and Intergovernmental Relations Committee recommendation to implement process enhancements for the performance evaluations for appointed staff.

Body
Committee Chair:
Dimple Ajmera, Budget, Governance, and Intergovernmental Relations

Staff Resource(s):
Sheila Simpson, Human Resources
Ryan Bergman, Strategy and Budget

Explanation
* On May 8, 2023, the Budget, Governance, and Intergovernmental Relations (BGIR) Committee Chair Ajmera briefed Mayor and City Council on the committee-proposed enhancements and updated timeline for conducting performance reviews of appointed staff positions (City Attorney, City Clerk and City Manager).
* Recommended process enhancements include to:
* Complete the current year performance evaluation process.
* Re-establish the regimen to conduct an annual performance evaluation with each appointee. Designate the fiscal year to be the performance period.
* Adopt a business practice to set goals for each appointee, within three to six months of the close of the strategy session where council's priorities and key initiatives are confirmed.
* Decide if Council wants to include a formal mid-year performance conference or maintain the current process of holding one annual, fiscal year-end performance conference.
* Have HR conduct training to inform Council of their appointee's performance evaluation process at New Council Member Orientation.

Committee Discussion
* On April 3 and May 1, 2023, the BGIR Committee received an overview of the current process for appointed employee performance evaluations, best practices for performance reviews, and discussed options for process enhancements.
* At the May 1st meeting, the committee voted to recommend the proposed process changes to full council (Council members Bokhari, Mayfield, and Mitchell voted in favor; Council members Ajmera and Anderson voted against).
* At the May 8th Counc...

Click here for full text